• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Black El Paso Voice

All Things Black in El Paso

  • Home
  • Newsletter
  • Black Roundtable

Opinion

Uncertain Times in a Divided Nation

February 16, 2025 by Monica Tucker

This may seem all over the place this Sunday morning, but currently, I’m in a space of sadness due to what my friends are experiencing. Some have lost their jobs and are now seeking places to live, a way to pay for their vehicles, etc.; but the message is clear. In these unsettling times, our nation is at a crossroads. In this battleground, corporate greed and outdated power structures wage war against multiculturalism, freedom, and the very principles of equality and justice. Extending far beyond economic concerns, the ongoing turmoil exuding from the current administration strikes at the core of who we are as a society. Our fundamental liberties are being stripped away.
Underrepresented communities are being further buried. Our nation took 10 steps backward from a 5-point lead; it demands immediate attention and concerted actions to protect the rights of all of us and uphold our collective commitment to equality, equity, fairness, and justice.
Corporate interests and political allies have made their true intent for far too long. They hid behind a facade that said, we are “fixing” a broken system. They have sown division among us, using centuries-old narratives of superiority and exclusion to maintain their grip on power.
They are trying to eliminate the systems we built for ourselves to further hinder our progress. From our initiatives, organizations, schools, etc., they aim to weaken us to thwart our collective abilities. The spaces built for people of color are not acts of reverse discrimination; they are necessary sanctuaries created because white spaces have historically been, and often continue to be, unwelcoming and hostile. Colonization was, and remains, a form of theft—of land, culture, and dignity.
Recent events have only deepened the wounds inflicted by systemic racism. In the past 27 days, countless individuals have been left angry, heartbroken, and overwhelmed as jobs, homes, and hopes are being stripped away. But even in the face of these relentless assaults, our resolve must not waver. Now more than ever, we must come together to rebuild from the ground up. Why from the ground up? Because we must admit, somewhere we got it wrong too. Change begins at home, in the neighborhoods, and in families, which form the backbone of our society.
The strategy of our oppressors is clear: to keep us divided by denying the existence of the very discrimination that they perpetuate. The current powers-that-be are tearing apart our communities while aiming to rewrite the constitution and engineer a society where human dignity and fundamental rights are privileges reserved for a select few. Their rhetoric of “making America great” is a cruel irony—a hollow promise that enriches the few while condemning the many to struggle without the basic necessities of life.
Today, I’m angry, mad, sad, and rightfully so. Some say that emotions aren’t allowed. I say emotions evoked movements. Our ancestors were angry, sad, and upset, but they dried their eyes, put emotions to the side and worked. But again, those EMOTIONS, created movements that brought us freedoms.
We are witnessing the inhumane and painful consequences of the actions of these evil perpetrators who are causing harm to hardworking U.S. citizens who have just begun to build their futures and now are depressed and stressed at finding ways to support their families.
Jobs are disappearing, homes will go into foreclosure, and the lifeline of hope is fraying under the weight of greed and neglect of people who shouldn’t even be making decisions on our behalf. Those perpetrators are oblivious to the struggles of everyday citizens. Their actions are a stark reminder that we are expendable in the eyes of those in power.
While unity is our strength, we have to be mindful that, as the old saying goes, “not all skinfolk are kinfolk.” Be careful; not everyone who looks like us is our battle buddy. We must protect and preserve our culture, ensuring that our growth is not co-opted by those who have historically sown division.
What we are experiencing is what the need for solidarity looks like. Now is not the time for what organization or person wants exposure for “Me-isms” while overlooking the obvious. Looking inward to our communities and families, let’s build bonds meant to be built and forge alliances that can only positively enforce our situation. If you are feeling overwhelmed by the current state of our nation, seek support from one another, share resources, and, above all, remain steadfast in our pursuit of justice.
In the face of adversity, we must keep fighting—for our rights, dignity, and hopeful future.
Stay strong, and above all, keep the flame.
Pray for our leaders and so-called leaders, our community, our nation, and ourselves.
The battle is far from over, but together, we can reclaim our nation and restore the true meaning of democracy.

Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: Opinion

Renard Johnson for Mayor: Founder’s Statement

November 5, 2024 by Monica Tucker

It is no secret that the final day of a major political election brings out most voters. Today, I hope everyone who didn’t vote early, does their part in choosing who is right to assist with positive progress.

Living in El Paso as a military spouse, mother, businesswoman, community activist, and advocate for almost 30 years, I have gained clarity and understanding concerning what it takes and who it takes to lead our community forward. Understanding the intersection of resilience, dedication, and vision, this current season of change is reflective of my beliefs and where I believe that we, as a community, go from here.

Our city is not without complex issues, and because of that, it takes people who are compassionate, non-combative leaders, to help us attain a greater level of being seen as a city that invites new innovations for job creation, improved safety, and better quality of life, among other things.

Heightening my commitment to the well-being of El Paso, I have chosen roles that shape my perspective and have accompanied my heart and mind since a young age, and my heart is for El Paso. Renard Johnson embodies these qualities that our city needs now more than ever. He genuinely understands the challenges and aspirations that define El Paso and is a proven leader in business who exudes compassion when it comes to having a heart for the community.

Renard is the only candidate for mayor who stepped forward to ensure our military families, especially military spouses, are included in the progress of our city and is positioned to drive the growth we need to be an inviting city to new and expanding industries.

I’m not only convinced but assured that Renard is a leaders leader who is caring enough to understand that we, the people, are a part of the necessary group that should be included in leading our city.

Monica Tucker

  • Founder, Black El Paso Voice/The Black Roundtable
  • Community Activist, Advocate, Volunteer
  • Mother, Grandmother
  • Businesswoman
  • Military Spouse – 34+ years
  • El Pasoan – 28+ years
  • Positivity Promoter – Since birth
Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: BEP Voice Weekly, Opinion, Politics

Minerva Torres Shelton for Sheriff: Founder’s Statement

November 5, 2024 by Monica Tucker

Everyone who knows me knows that besides Northeast El Paso, the sheriff’s department and who we have as a leader is important to me because I want our deputies to be safe, and we want the corruption to end! My opinion is unpopular, but the other candidate can’t hold a candle to Minerva regarding experience, honesty, and diplomacy. She does not have a negative agenda.

My vote is actually for Sgt. James Brown. She will provide the leadership necessary to ensure we won’t lose our service members to ignorance. Our law enforcement community deserves better, and change is needed in the sheriff’s department. Don’t let the party affiliation fool you; Minerva Torres Shelton is the experienced leader El Paso needs to revitalize the Sheriff’s Department. She has over 25 years of law enforcement training and experience, including a distinguished tenure with the FBI and serving our country in the Army in military intelligence.

Her expertise and vision make her the ONLY candidate on the ballot to address systemic issues that plague the county law enforcement division. Minerva began her law enforcement career as a patrol officer with the EPPD, where she enhanced her experience in community policing and public safety. She started her career with the FBI, as with many, after September 11, 2001. In this role, she led critical investigations into violent crimes, human trafficking, and counterterrorism.

As a Supervisory Special Agent, her experience with the Joint Terrorism Task Force and her work on human trafficking initiatives demonstrate her commitment to protecting vulnerable populations. Transparency and accountability, which are essential in the role of the sheriff to end corruption, is where her approach is focused on restoring trust in the Sheriff’s Department.

Who we elect is crucial to the safety of our deputies and the department’s operations. She has a plethora of strategies to enhance public safety while prioritizing mental health support within our jails.

Minerva Torres Shelton is not just another candidate; she is the ONLY candidate who has demonstrated passion for advocacy for fair justice. Neither a consensus nor a survey is needed to understand that we’ll risk further mistrust and mishandling if we don’t transfer leadership to a more experienced candidate. Her aim is to create a Sheriff’s Department that reflects the values of El Paso—integrity, service, and community engagement.

Hands down, she is unmatched when it comes to experience, integrity, and commitment. How do you throw safety out the window? By voting for the least experienced person.

Monica Tucker

  • Founder, Black El Paso Voice/The Black Roundtable
  • Community Activist, Advocate, Volunteer
  • Mother, Grandmother
  • Businesswoman
  • Military Spouse – 34+ years
  • El Pasoan – 28+ years
  • Positivity Promoter – Since birth
Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: BEP Voice Weekly, Opinion, Politics

Cynthia Boyar Trejo for District 4 NE Rep: Founder’s Statement

November 5, 2024 by Monica Tucker

I’ve had the privilege of speaking and getting to know Cynthia Boyar Trejo, and it’s clear to me that she’s uniquely suited to represent Northeast El Paso. As a third-generation El Pasoan and an Andress High School graduate, Cynthia knows our community’s values and challenges firsthand.

As the founder of a nonprofit focused on underserved populations, she has over 20 years of business experience. Expanding economic growth and improving the quality of life for all Northeast residents is what she is dedicated to achieving with the help of those she will serve.

She is passionate and dedicated, as many of us are when it comes to changing the narrative about the Northeast and showcasing the potential for growth and opportunity. She is committed to community-driven solutions and ensuring the residents of Northeast El Paso have a voice because she genuinely understands the need to be heard and valued.

Solid leadership, years of executive coaching, and hands-on community work, I have no doubt she is ready to advocate for vital services, attract new businesses, and create opportunities that benefit all of El Paso.

Monica Tucker

  • Founder, Black El Paso Voice/The Black Roundtable
  • Community Activist, Advocate, Volunteer
  • Mother, Grandmother
  • Businesswoman
  • Military Spouse – 34+ years
  • El Pasoan – 28+ years
  • Positivity Promoter – Since birth
Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: BEP Voice Weekly, Opinion, Politics

Ask El Paso Voters if they still want a Downtown venue

July 14, 2024 by Courtesy of El Paso Matters

Opinion: Ask El Paso voters if they still want a Downtown venue

by Special to El Paso Matters, El Paso Matters
July 14, 2024


By city Rep. Chris Canales

Joined by city representatives Brian Kennedy and Art Fierro, I placed an item on the agenda for Tuesday’s City Council meeting calling for a proposition on the ballot in the November 2024 election to ask voters if they want to revoke the city’s authority to issue bonds for the Multipurpose Performing Arts and Entertainment Facility (commonly called the “Downtown arena” or the “MPC”), effectively ending the project. 

Chris Canales

The MPC’s proposed Downtown location is in my district, so I feel the need to explain why we think this is an important question to pose to El Paso’s voters.

Bond laws are complex, but the City Council has the legal option to make this decision ourselves without an election, to choose not to issue these bonds and abandon the project due to a material change in circumstances. Instead, I feel it is appropriate to ask El Pasoans how they want to proceed. 

Voters have been waiting 12 long years since the passage of the 2012 quality of life bond election for some resolution on the MPC project, and after so much time they should have their voices heard again at the ballot box.

This is a project that the current City Council should never have even inherited. In the 12 years since the MPC project was first approved, the project has, through a series of high profile headwinds and hang-ups, morphed into something that no longer resembles the initial concept.

The reality now, in 2024, is that there is nowhere near the amount of funding required to deliver an “arena” – a project of that scale would cost something in the range of $400-$500 million, not the $128 million remaining in unsold bonds. 

Even the $128 million in new debt would exert significant pressure on the city’s tax rate for years to come. While the city of El Paso is doing better than many peer cities in our recovery from the economic difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, that recovery is still in progress. Our citizens are still feeling the impact in the form of inflation and increased cost of living. 

This raises the vital question of whether the timing is right for such a sizable debt-funded project. That question is one that I think the city must now pose to the public, which is why we are proposing this for inclusion on the ballot in November.

I won’t say that the proposal of the MPC project was the wrong decision in 2012. The economic context was very different more than a decade ago, and a whole lot of socioeconomic upheaval has happened since then. 

I also won’t say that building a large entertainment venue in Downtown would definitely be a bad idea for El Paso’s post-recovery future. Just as the context has changed since 2012, it will continue to change with the march of time, and there may be a future in which the idea of a Downtown arena can be reconceptualized, realistically priced out, and proposed to the voters again as a far more complete package, including a specific location. 

That option is far better than continuing to modify the existing project again and again to the point where it is no longer recognizable or even wanted by its original supporters. 

If a Downtown arena is desired in the future, El Pasoans deserve to make a decision about such a large project with full knowledge of what will be developed, the potential benefits and challenges, and of course the real cost to the taxpayers.

I don’t want to presume that the proposition on the ballot will pass and the MPC project in its current iteration will be ended. There is of course the possibility that the public will choose not to revoke the city’s bonding authority for the project, implicitly saying that the project should move forward. 

There is a current proposal to build an 8,000 capacity indoor/outdoor hybrid venue next to the Union Depot rail station that admittedly wasn’t very popular. After years of prior city councils pivoting and studying alternatives, I believe that this proposal is the most viable option if the project does move forward, but I know many others do not agree. 

If the City Council doesn’t pass this agenda item, or if the voters don’t ultimately pass the proposition, I’m sure there will still be plenty of discussion about what direction to go in next. We will cross that bridge if we come to it, or more aptly if the voters lead us to it.

Chris Canales has served as city representative for District 8 on the El Paso City Council, which includes Downtown, since January 2023.

This article first appeared on El Paso Matters and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Courtesy of El Paso Matters
elpasomatters.org

Filed Under: Opinion

Opinion: Embracing Diversity in Faith-based Civic Engagement, Politics, Community Building, and Involvement

July 14, 2024 by Monica Tucker

As a person of faith deeply engaged in our community, I feel compelled to offer a more nuanced perspective on the intersection of faith/religion, politics, and civic engagement. God may have called one to float and one to fly.

Following yesterday’s incident with the former president, quite a few voices have emerged, each presenting their perspective on the who, what, when, where, and why –  blasé skippy. 

Our diverse Christian community is a kaleidoscope of individual gifts, talents, and callings. It’s important to remember that God’s gifts are not distributed to each person the same; what one person is called to do may differ greatly from another’s. The assumption that one’s personal convictions should be universal is a dangerous oversimplification of faith and civic duty. While we are one in the body of Christ, our delivery methods will vary.

In my view, the belief that one political party holds a monopoly on righteousness is fundamentally flawed. Our society is complex and faces various challenges that rarely have simple, one-sided solutions. As people of faith, we should be wary of partisan entrenchment and instead strive for a more nuanced understanding of the issues at hand.

Rather than silencing voices that don’t align with our personal views, we should create spaces for respectful dialogue. It’s through these conversations that we can hope to bridge divides and find common ground on the issues that affect our communities most deeply.

Engaging with current events and politics can profoundly express faith when approached with integrity and compassion.

However, we must do so with humility, recognizing the limitations of our own understanding and remaining open to growth and new perspectives.To those who would seek to silence voices of faith in the public square, I say this: What you’re not going to do is stifle the diverse group of believers who know they are called to engage in civic discourse. Our faith compels us to be active participants in shaping our society for the better. I don’t need a doctorate in theology to know that or elicit approval.

Just because God didn’t give it to you, doesn’t mean he didn’t give it to another. Each of us have different gifts, talents, and levels of capacity. Your opinion believing one political party is better than the other is your first mistake.

All things should be done decently and in order, with pure intent. Don’t allow emotions to move you in the wrong direction. Emotions often shape opinions, but decisions should be based on facts. Use emotions as motivation, but let reason guide your actions. Balance feeling with thinking for better outcomes.

Regardless, as Christians, we may know and opine about the facts, but our behavior should reflect purity in all things. No one knows why yesterday happened, but I pray for all parties involved and pray deeply for an end to the nonsense discourse that encourage these unnecessary tragedies. 

As we move forward, let’s focus on building a community values diverse perspectives, encourages thoughtful engagement, and remains grounded in our shared faith values. The challenges we face are bigger than any one of us – it’s time we start acting like it

Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: Opinion

Removing the Rug: Addressing Community Challenges Head-On

June 20, 2024 by Monica Tucker

This week, we will share the videos of each speaker from the State of Black El Paso, which took place on Juneteenth, 2024.

We have removed the rug. We’ve burned it.

Everyone who participated shared their thoughts and information on how to grow better together. Our community can be more inclusive and less degrading if we have hard conversations followed by active, empowering solutions. Community building cannot take place without first tearing down the walls that divide us.

Truth is everything.

Without acknowledging the causes of destruction, how can you ensure a more positive future? From civil rights to socioeconomic standing, a community is only as strong as its leaders. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Malcolm X, Fannie Lou Hamer, and others fought with words. If that’s not you, have a seat, but don’t try to stop what God is doing, and that is the very thing you prayed for – a more diverse and forward-moving El Paso.

Where Are Black Leaders in the Community?
Despite what you’ve heard, we are here. A leader isn’t just someone who holds a position within a community, company, or organization. A leader unapologetically takes their role as a citizen to do what’s right for the greater good.

A leader uses their voice and is not silenced or afraid of the faces of those who continue to use negativity to stunt our growth. Despite your socioeconomic status, if you’re in any part of the community/society that believes racism doesn’t exist on the border, that the Black community is just fine, and that you have no issues, and believe that some of us are “doing too much” to actualize unity… stay over there, especially if you are Black identifying. The hypocrisy is if you have those beliefs yet work in fields that combat ageism, classism, elitism, racism, sexism, etc.

Stay tuned this week as you hear the words from those who, like myself, desire positive community growth and change. We share collective goals of improving and being a part of the solution instead of adding to the problems.

I’m not going to be in El Paso forever. Still, like I have previously stated: “If my children choose to remain here, I want them to know I did all that I could to try to bridge the divide and bring us closer to inclusion, representation, and Black self-empowerment and pride…unashamedly… while connecting with various other cultures on the border.” 

So, no more sweeping stuff under the rug. Let’s talk about it, but only for a short time. We’re adults – it doesn’t take long to screw in a light bulb.

=======

 

Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: Community Voices, Juneteenth, Opinion

Choosing Not to Associate: A Decision Rooted in Values, Not Ill Will

May 23, 2024 by Monica Tucker

I absolutely support local arts organizations. My family, friends, and community co-laborers are artistic. Our goals include advancing the movement.

Transparency as a professional and community activist: As publishers, making decisions about supporting organizations in our local community can be challenging. Ultimately, we prioritize what is best for our publication, readers, and family, ensuring our choices align with our core values and mission.

Transparency: The Question – Why are you choosing not to associate your name and brand with the new black arts organization? | As a parent, I ensure my children’s well-being and comfort, regardless of age. In addition, protecting your name and brand is crucial during these times. Specific individuals associated with a local supposed cultural arts organization have demonstrated behavior that is detrimental to a positive and supportive artistic environment. These actions have caused significant concern and discomfort for people, including my family. We have chosen not to associate ourselves with the organization. We want nothing but the best for any initiative meant to advance the culture as long as harmful tactics aren’t used to do so.

This choice is rooted in our commitment to maintaining a safe, ethical, and nurturing space for artistic expression. We believe that creative endeavors should be pursued in an atmosphere free from anxiety, toxicity, or any form of negative influence.

Our non-participation is not a reflection on the importance of Black arts in our community but rather a stance against specific behaviors and attitudes incompatible with our values and the well-being of artists.

We remain committed to supporting and promoting Black arts through other avenues that align with our principles of respect, integrity, and positive community building.

Our activation of a positive local Black Arts initiative is not hindered by the pause in our efforts due to intellectual property issues; it will continue as it has since prior to meeting the current leadership of the aforementioned.

Transparency: Official Statement | The organization’s inception is marred by intellectual theft and a betrayal of trust, as the concept and name were originally my daughter’s idea. The individual who appropriated this idea has shown a troubling lack of integrity, not only by using my daughter’s concept but also by admitting to using psychological manipulation for personal gain against others as stated by the individual themselves.

My decision is not a hasty one, but a result of a steadfast commitment to authenticity, safety, and moral principles. By placing my family’s well-being at the forefront and aligning with those who uphold honesty, respect, and civility, I am consciously distancing myself from potentially toxic and harmful influences.

I firmly believe that true artistic and cultural movements should be founded on genuine creativity, mutual respect, and positive community impact, not on manipulation and false narratives.

I choose to adhere to a path of integrity, even if it means standing apart from a different cultural movement that some have unfortunately embraced.

This approach reflects my belief that the quality of one’s associations and the ethical foundation of artistic endeavors are more important than mere popularity or scale.

My rejection of this association is not a rejection of Black arts or cultural expression but rather a principled stand against these essential concepts’ misappropriation and potential misuse.

It is a powerful reminder that the integrity of a movement’s leadership and founding principles is crucial to its true value and impact.

If you have an organization (arts or otherwise) that we can truly work with void of toxicity, let us know. Our goal is to work smarter, not harder because we are better together; however, please be genuine and have a loving care and concern for the community respecting the ethical and moral positive beliefs of others.

If your goal is to deceive and manipulate people, I can’t recommend nor participate.

It’s time for real change.

Timeline

2021: My daughter and I discussed her interest in starting a local organization for Black citizens involved in various artistic disciplines.

2022: We began to develop the concept, incorporating ideas from previous initiatives that I and her godfather had envisioned for Black El Paso Voice in the late 90’s. As my daughter was busy with school, I took the lead in identifying local artists and briefly shared the information with a newcomer to El Paso.

August 2023: I revisited the idea with this new individual, who found the concept unique and brilliant and agreed to participate.

Early September 2023: The individual revealed toxic and harmful behavior. To protect Black men focused on community building and myself, we severed ties after the person admitted to using their psychology background to manipulate someone.

The Following Week: The person began circulating the name “El Paso Black Arts Association,” which was the name my daughter had intended for her organization that I shared with this individual as the hope was to plan for Black History Month 2024 due to the theme of: African Americans and the Arts. This was a regrettable outcome of sharing our plans with the person. 

Since Then: The situation has been challenging, with continued falsehoods and cyberstalking despite my requests for no further communication. In addition, several well-respected people in our community informed me that I should inform the community that I have no ties with the person due to her behavior with them as well. I chose to remain silent but in doing so, the situation worsened. I was told that I should protect my name and business as this person was mentioning both in meetings and public spaces. 

Moving Forward: My daughter remains undeterred and will continue to pursue her dream of creating an arts organization for the Black community that encourages engagement with other cultures. She has not allowed the theft of her intellectual property to stop her.

I cannot support toxic activity from those who are supposed leaders. Our values do not align, as I am committed to positive community building and not negative manipulation. Not that it matters, but because my faith was questioned, I not only love God, but follow the principles of love, grace, faith, and forgiveness, and will continue to follow the guidance of the Holy Spirit, unapologetically.

I do not dismiss anyone whose spiritual beliefs are akin to mine; however, I do not condone certain practices that may cause harm to others, including mentally, physically, or socially.

My prayers will forever include those whose behaviors are harmful to others, asking God to deliver them from evil. 

Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: Opinion

The Vital Role of Gatekeeping in Community Building

February 11, 2024 by Monica Tucker

“Ensuring the safety and integrity of your name, brand, business, family, and community is not gatekeeping; it’s protection.”

 

The Vital Role of Gatekeeping in Community Building: To move forward, we must expose those who claim to do good but are bad actors in the community.

As someone deeply committed to strengthening community bonds and fostering collaboration, I often find myself navigating the delicate balance between promoting unity and addressing the challenges posed by adult bullies within our community. Throughout my extensive involvement in various community initiatives over the years, I’ve encountered individuals whose toxic behavior has necessitated implementing gatekeeping measures to protect the well-being of our collective pursuits.

During an interview, I faced the disturbing reality of intentional exploitation by a community member. This individual shamelessly admitted to exploiting others’ perceived weaknesses, displaying a blatant disregard for ethical conduct and empathy. Decisive action was needed to prevent further harm to unsuspecting collaborators.

In grappling with the moral dilemma of whether to intervene and alert others, I confronted the harsh truth of how manipulative individuals can perpetuate falsehoods and inflict lasting damage on our community. Despite initially hoping for personal growth and redemption, I realized the urgency of prioritizing the protection of vulnerable individuals from exploitation and deceit.

Though challenging, I decided to cut ties with such individuals because I felt a deep sense of responsibility to safeguard the integrity of our community initiatives. Witnessing the insidious spread of falsehoods and intellectual property theft underscored the importance of distinguishing between genuine allies and opportunistic detractors.

Furthermore, my dedication to shielding loved ones from potential harm led me to withdraw from collaborations tainted by deceit and manipulation. This sobering realization emphasized the necessity of vigilant gatekeeping to preserve the integrity of our shared endeavors, even in familial contexts.

In prioritizing authenticity and integrity over superficial alliances, I found solace in my daughter’s commitment to pursuing her artistic vision independently. Despite facing setbacks orchestrated by deceptive actors, her resilience in amplifying Black voices in the community served as a beacon of hope amidst adversity.

Reflecting on these experiences, I’m compelled to initiate an honest dialogue within our community about the nuanced dynamics of gatekeeping and its role in promoting inclusivity and safety. While gatekeeping can evoke mixed reactions, its importance lies in distinguishing between constructive standards and exclusionary practices.

Bad gatekeeping, characterized by arbitrary criteria and discriminatory practices, fosters a hostile environment that undermines community cohesion. Such behaviors erode trust and perpetuate divisiveness, harming the fabric of our community.

Conversely, good gatekeeping serves as a defense against toxicity and exploitation, maintaining the integrity of our shared spaces and promoting accountability and mutual respect. By setting clear standards and boundaries, gatekeepers uphold the values that define our community and mitigate the risk posed by malicious actors.

To safeguard our collective well-being, we must recognize the pivotal role of good gatekeepers and support and empower individuals who demonstrate integrity and compassion in their stewardship of community resources. Whether through formal leadership roles or grassroots initiatives, fostering a culture of accountability is essential for our community’s growth.

Moving forward, I advocate for a proactive approach to gatekeeping that prioritizes transparency, inclusivity, and education. By encouraging open dialogue and promoting diversity, we can overcome the barriers posed by toxic behavior and build a community grounded in trust and solidarity.

Bad Gatekeeping

Bad gatekeeping is exclusionary and discriminatory, often based on arbitrary or superficial criteria. It can be harmful to individuals’ mental health and create toxic environments by barring people from participating in a community based on things like how big of a fan they are or the circumstances of their discovery of the community.

This form of gatekeeping can be particularly damaging in fan communities, where the joy of shared interest should be inclusive and where gatekeeping can be used to exclude typically underrepresented groups, such as women or people of color, based on prejudiced views.

In summary, good gatekeeping protects the essential characteristics of a community and ensures its members are qualified or aligned with its goals. In contrast, lousy gatekeeping is exclusionary, often based on prejudice, and harms the community by creating a hostile and unwelcoming environment.

Good Gatekeeping (When it goes right, keeping toxic people from harming others and their pursuits.)

Good gatekeeping involves setting and maintaining standards, boundaries, or rules necessary for functioning or preserving a community’s core values and purpose. It can be a form of quality control that ensures the integrity of a community or activity is maintained.

For example, in professional or specialized communities, gatekeeping can ensure members have the necessary skills or knowledge to contribute effectively. This type of gatekeeping is often seen as essential to keep countercultures vibrant and thriving, as it can prevent the dilution of a community’s unique culture or the misrepresentation of its values. Good gatekeepers play a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of a community by keeping toxic individuals out to prevent harm. They serve as protectors of the community’s well-being and values.

However, good gatekeepers need to exercise their role responsibly, ensuring that their actions are based on transparent and fair criteria and that they do not engage in discriminatory or exclusionary practices. Good gatekeeping should focus on preserving the community’s positive aspects and promoting a safe and inclusive environment for all members.

In essence, gatekeeping is a means of nurturing communities built on trust, integrity, and inclusivity. We can dismantle barriers and create a future defined by genuine collaboration and mutual respect.

Gatekeeping operates in various contexts, impacting advocates within communities as well. Here are some examples:

  1. Media Advocacy: Advocates often engage in media advocacy, where gatekeeping involves pitching stories or perspectives to journalists or editors. Gatekeepers in media ultimately decide which stories get coverage, shaping public discourse on social issues.
  2. Healthcare Advocacy: Within healthcare, advocates may encounter gatekeeping when advocating for improved access to healthcare services or challenging discriminatory practices. Gatekeepers in healthcare settings, such as insurers or healthcare administrators, may control access to resources and services.
  3. Social Media Advocacy: Advocates utilize social media platforms to amplify their messages and mobilize support for causes. However, through content moderation policies or algorithmic decisions, gatekeeping by social media platforms can impact the visibility and reach of advocacy efforts.
  4. Community Advocacy: Gatekeeping can also occur within community advocacy efforts, where specific individuals or groups may control access to decision-making processes or resources. Advocates may face challenges navigating these gatekeepers to advocate for community needs effectively.
  5. Policy Advocacy: Advocates working to influence policy decisions may encounter gatekeeping within governmental or organizational structures. Gatekeepers in policymaking processes, such as legislators or government officials, can shape policy agendas and determine which voices are heard.
  6. Funding Advocacy: Securing funding is essential for sustaining advocacy efforts, but gatekeeping by funders can pose challenges. Gatekeepers in philanthropic organizations or grant-making institutions may prioritize specific issues or approaches, affecting which advocacy initiatives receive support.
  7. Intersectional Advocacy: Advocates working at the intersections of multiple social justice issues may face additional layers of gatekeeping. Intersectional gatekeeping can arise from entrenched power dynamics and systemic inequalities, requiring advocates to navigate complex barriers to achieve meaningful change.

Gatekeeping can have significant impacts on marginalized communities in various ways. These examples demonstrate how gatekeeping can hinder marginalized communities’ inclusivity, representation, and progress in various spheres. 

  1. Exclusion of Marginalized Voices: Gatekeeping can exclude individuals or groups with valuable perspectives, limiting diversity and representation within movements or communities.
  2. Fragmentation and Divisiveness: Strict gatekeeping can lead to internal conflicts and the marginalization of voices that do not fit within predefined boundaries, contributing to fragmentation and divisiveness within grassroots movements.
  3. Replication of Power Structures: Gatekeeping can perpetuate existing power imbalances, making it challenging for minoritized individuals to persist in certain fields such as STEMM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics, and Medicine).
  4. Cultural Gatekeeping: In creative industries, cultural gatekeeping by the dominant group can limit the opportunities and recognition of marginalized creators, reinforcing existing power dynamics.
  5. Reduced Community Engagement: High barriers and exclusive cliques created by gatekeeping can alienate and intimidate community members, reducing engagement and limiting the potential for widespread mobilization.

In navigating these contexts, advocates must strategically address gatekeeping challenges, build alliances, and advocate for transparency and inclusivity in decision-making processes. By recognizing and confronting gatekeeping barriers, advocates can work towards fostering more equitable and inclusive communities.

In solidarity and commitment to collective growth,

Monica Tucker

Community Advocate and Activist

Publisher: Black El Paso Voice News & Information

Monica Tucker

Monica is the founder and publisher of Black El Paso Voice. She is an advocate fighting against racism and embracing positive community involvement. She is a lover of God, Puerto Rican cuisine, and the greatest defender of her family. She also enjoy House Music and swears it’s the best music on the planet!

blackelpasovoice.com

Filed Under: Black History Month, Opinion

Trouble in the Borderland

March 18, 2023 by Marcus McCoy

March 12, 2023, was a day like no other in El Paso, Texas. Hundreds of people tried to force their way into El Paso via the Paso Del Norte Bridge located in downtown El Paso. The scene was frantic and served as yet another reminder of a larger issue. Border Patrol agents and other law enforcement agencies did their best to control the situation. There are always people trying to enter the country illegally through El Paso, but in recent years it has never been this chaotic with this mass number of individuals.

The answers to many questions we seek answers, for now, rest in the hands of local city officials, city leaders, state legislators, and those who serve at our border entry points. This should serve as a call to action for the city of El Paso. The upcoming days and weeks will provide vital information on how the city will move forward. Progression must be the focal point.

Marcus McCoy

I am a proud father, advocate for education, community supporter, and podcast host.

Filed Under: Opinion

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Advertisement

Footer

  • About
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Contact

Connect Online

  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Categories

  • News & Information
  • City of El Paso
  • Community News
  • FBI El Paso Updates
  • Business

Refund Policy

Refund Policy | Disclaimer

Copyright ©Black El Paso Voice | Site Maintained by MOCHA